Ohio's Shale-Drilling Shows Signs of a Re-Boom Though Not to Everyone's Delight

Oct 24, 2017

Ohio’s oil and gas drilling boom started in 2010, peaked in 2013 and has been fading since then.  Now there are signs it may be picking up again. 

Larry Hecht runs Pier-48 intermodal loading site in Wellsville
Credit Tim Rudell / WKSU

Larry Hecht runs Pier-48 on the Ohio River.  It’s an intermodal terminal for loading and off-loading barges.

At the height of the shale boom it got 25 bulk shipments of drilling supplies like barite a month. Then came the bust, and that traffic stopped.

But Hecht had expanded the pier’s materials handling capabilities in the up-times, so he found new materials to handle.

“So, I had the opportunity to do soy beans, because I can off-load a soybean barge through the conveyer.  And that was really my lifesaver for that period, that lull; it was the soybeans.  I actually did some corn,too.”

Signs of a comeback?
Now, Hecht says the adjusting he did to keep the business going is about to pay off.  Advanced bookings are coming in from drillers again and he believes that’s a sign energy companies are gearing up for a new run at the Utica Shale.  

Andrew Thomas of the Levin School at Cleveland State University
Credit Tim Rudell / WKSU

Andrew Thomas, executive-in-residence of Cleveland State University’s Maxine Goodman Levin College of Urban Affairs, agrees. The university just finished a study of Ohio‘s shale play and he says it has unique economic factors to carry it forward.

For one, Ohio is not what's called an extractive economy.

“We are not like Oklahoma where we make our living off oil and gas upstream business.  The Ohio economy uses oil and gas, especially natural gas. So, the fact that we have these depressed prices is spurring a lot of that economic activity in Ohio.” 

Was the bust really a bust?
Another thing about the Utica Shale boom and bust is that the bust may not have exactly been that. At least not in terms of unemployment and careers ending in the region.

When the oil and gas markets collapsed, energy infrastructure-building was well under way in Ohio. So, whether for welders or engineers, many jobs just shifted from drilling to pipelines and power plants.

Attorney Alan Wenger practices law in the energy sector and follows the industry closely. He says the trained workers are still here and actively pursuing their careers.

Those folks, they may have to travel a few hours and stay in hotels, but they have work. There’s no question.”  

Jim Kiefer, home owner near drilling pad/pump site
Credit Tim Rudell / WKSU

Opposite view
Not everyone is enthusiastic about a drilling comeback. General environmental concerns remain, as do specific concerns about the quality of the work being done. Those were raised by problems such as the Rover pipeline's leak during construction  contaminating wetlands in Stark County.

And, there are individuals with personal property concerns — raised by experiences like Jim Kiefer’s when a compressor station was put next to his Carroll County house.

"And they say, 'We’re gonna start using explosives.’  And I said I was never informed. ‘Well somebody should-of told you.’

"And within a couple minutes it was like something in a World War II movie: this huge explosion and the dirt and rocks flew up in the air. And the sound waves just moved through the home and terrified me and the dogs.  And it was just awful.” 

Different time, different circumstances
Paul Feezel, also of Carroll County. is a financial consultant.  And he heads the conservation group Concerned Citizens of Carroll.  

Carrollton truck traffic, 2017
Credit Tim Rudell / WKSU

As he watches renewed truck traffic passing Carrollton’s square, he says a return to drilling does seem likely, but may be less positive than people expect.

“There’s no doubt that there are people who say, 'Come back, I want my share. Come drill my property.' But I have a feeling those people are still thinking about the boom kind of numbers, not the kind of numbers that are out there now at the oil prices we’ve got, and the liquids prices we’ve got.” 

Following the money
Cleveland State’s study shows that over the past five years -- even with half of that time in the downturn -- Ohio's shale play drew $54.7 billion in investment. And CSU’s Andrew Thomas says that early on, while drilling was still active, a lot of that money went to companies and workers from out of state. But later, with the shift to infrastructure building, most of it stayed here.

“On the post-drilling side, which has to do with handling and storage and piping, that’s probably closer to 70 or 80 percent.” 

Drillin crew in 2011 in Carroll County
Credit Tim Rudell / WKSU

The way it looks right now
In the shale fields, the drilling-rig count is slowly increasing. And around the region, projects that can create sustained demand for eastern Ohio natural gas here are in the works, including $12 billion in chemical processing complexes, and 11 new gas-fired power plants.